Posts Categorized: NSW Courts

Severity Appeal Succeeds as Sentencing Judge Failed to Consider Alternatives to Prison

Severity Appeal Succeeds as Sentencing Judge Failed to Consider Alternatives to Prison

By Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim Kevin Vazquez checked into the Drummoyne Furnished Apartments on 20 June 2023, and on 21 July, he contacted the manager informing a consignment addressed to an “Alejandro Evans” arriving from the US was his. After arrival, of what was being referred as the “dummy run”, Vazquez took various photos… Read more »

Convictions for Hindering Police and Offensive Language Quashed Due to Illegal Search

Train station

By Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim On being approached by several New South Wales police officers in Potts Point on 3 October 2023, Daniel Karlsson admitted he did not have a ticket to be travelling on public transport. On hearing this admission, police constable Moriarty asked Karlsson to identify himself, and as the civilian did,… Read more »

Retrial Ordered for Drug Importation Case as Judge Incorrectly Explained Law to Jury

Appeal court

By Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim Timothy John Engstrom was running a business called Bungendore Landscape Supplies, together with business partner Adam Hunter in June 2019, when the latter decided to import a Caterpillar excavator from overseas, whist it had 384 packets of cocaine secreted in the arm of the vehicle. The total pure weight… Read more »

Drug Offence Appeal Highlights Difficulties in Establishing Parity in Sentencing

Supreme courts window

By Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim Toby Weekes, Jackson Chaker and a number of other individuals had been engaged in an unlawful commercial cannabis enterprise in regional communities in central west New South Wales over 2021 through to 2022. And after the operation was closed down, Weekes was charged with four counts of supplying a… Read more »

NSW Supreme Court’s Reasons for Maintaining Major Events Declaration for Herzog Visit

The NSW Supreme Court found that the major event declaration providing for extraordinary policing powers during the Herzog visit was warranted.

by Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim Organiser Josh Lees and the Palestine Action Group sought to have the order declaring the official visit of Israeli president Isaac Herzog to Sydney commencing on 9 February 2026 a major event and hence, enliven extraordinary policing powers revoked by the NSW Supreme Court on the same day that… Read more »

NSW to Prohibit the Use of ‘Good Character’ as a Mitigating Factor in Sentencing

NSW to Prohibit the Use of ‘Good Character’ as a Mitigating Factor in Sentencing

by Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim In a move that has long been demanded by victim advocacy groups and is based upon a recommendation contained in a New South Wales Sentencing Council report of July 2025,  the state government has introduced legislation that would prohibit the use of ‘good character’ as a factor which has… Read more »