By Paul Gregoire and Ugur Nedim.
Western Sydney man Jamal Zahab has had his sentence reduced after an appeal over a charge of assault with intent to rob in company. This was in respect of an April 2023 robbery at a Bankstown hotel, which involved two co-accused entering the establishment allegedly armed with a firearm in a failed attempt to rob the place. And Zahab’s knowledge of the firearm, or lack thereof, was key to his appeal.
At 11.23 am on 14 April 2023, Jamal Zahab, who was driving a stolen Range Rover Discovery, picked up Nirmal Suman from his Bankstown home. Suman got in the passenger seat, whilst Bilal Helou was already in the back seat. The trio then drove to a nearby hotel and parked at the rear exit of its carpark. Suman and Helou then entered the bar, with workers onsite considering they had a gun.
Suman and Helou approached hotel licensee Justin Pham. One assailant said “This is a hold-up. Go into the office.” Pham tried to flee, but Helou and Suman grabbed him and wrenched a lanyard off his neck, which had the office keys. Pham did not sustain any injuries from this assault, but he refused to enter the office, so Suman raised the “supposed firearm” to get him to follow orders.
Pham alleged that he heard a gunshot and at that point he fled the hotel, but there was no evidence of any bullet being fired. Suman and Helou then left without taking anything, and they tossed the keys at the feet of another worker. Helou was allegedly heard to say to Suman, “Put it away. Put it away.”
Zahab then drove the vehicle to a carpark in Punchbowl, five minutes away, and the men left on foot. The trio then made their way to Helou’s house, before Zahab and Suman continued on to the latter’s house, at which point, Zahab proceeded to head home.
Plea of guilty
In the New South Wales District Court in 2025, Zahab pleaded guilty to and faced one count of assault with intent to rob in company under section 97(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), which carries a maximum penalty of 20 years’ imprisonment.
NSW District Court Judge Gina O’Rourke SC outlined that the defendant was 43 at time of offending, and whilst the prosecution accepted his knowledge of the firearm could not be proven beyond reasonable doubt, it could neither be ignored that a gun was used in the crime. And whilst Zahab joined the enterprise late in the planning, the objective seriousness of the crime was still midrange.
Her Honour underscored that whilst Zahab claimed he was not aware he was joining an armed robbery, he joined the enterprise as he needed funds for his heroin habit, and he did drive the participants to the hotel, where they donned masks and gloves and entered it, whilst he sat in the car waiting to provide the getaway.
The court heard that Zahab suffered daily physical abuse from his father when a child, prior to his father then being brutally murdered. Further, the defendant started using heroin at 15. He too has a history of self-harm, and he suffers several mental conditions, including PTSD. And Zahab has spent 50 percent of his time in prison since he was in his early 20s.
Judge O’Rourke then sentenced Zahab to 4 years and 3 months imprisonment, with non-parole set at 2 years and 10 months, on 26 September 2026. This sentence reflected a 5 percent discount due to the utilitarian value of his early guilty plea.
In terms of his co-accused, Helou and Suman were sentence by Judge O’Rourke at an earlier time in respect of having pleaded guilty to assault with intent to rob while armed with a dangerous weapon, contrary to section 97(2) of the Crimes Act. This crime carries up to 25 years gaol time.
Sulman was sentenced to 6 years and 9 months in gaol, with non-parole set at 4 years and 6 months, while Helou was sentenced to 4 years and 9 months, with a non-parole period of 3 years and 2 months. Both these sentences reflected a 25 percent discount, due to their early guilty pleas.
Severity Appeal
Zahab then appealed against the severity of his sentence to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal (NSWCCA) on 29 June 2026. And he did so based on four grounds of appeal.
The first ground was that the sentencing judge factored his co-accuseds’ possession of a firearm into Zahab’s offending, contrary to the principle in the 1981 High Court case The Queen versus De Simoni, as the Crown had conceded knowledge of the weapon could not be shown beyond a reasonable doubt.
The second ground consisted of the sentencing judge failing to distinguish between Zahab’s liability for the offence, as a participant in a joint criminal enterprise, and his moral culpability due to his specific role in it.
The third ground involved the sentencing judge considering that Zahab’s deprived childhood reduced his moral culpability, but she then failed to consider how this bore on other purposes of sentencing.
The final ground consisted of Judge O’Rourke giving consideration to Zahab’s past offending, and specifically convictions in relation to possession of firearms, assault with intent to rob, and robbery armed with a dangerous weapon, despite none of these crimes appearing on his criminal record.
On moving towards the appeal, the Crown conceded that the third and fourth grounds were made out. So, the appeal itself was made out, and resentencing had to take place. However, Zahab sought to have the resentencing exercise address the matters dealt within the first two grounds, and therefore, the appeals court had to consider whether these grounds were made out too.
Ground one consisted of the De Simoni principle being breached. The principle consists of a court not being able to consider an aggravating factor of a crime that would have made it a more serious offence. With the presence of a firearm in this case warranting the offence that his co-accused faced being section 97(2)’s assault with intent to rob while armed with a dangerous weapon.
The three-justice bench of the appeals court considered that the principle more likely broken was that involved in the 2010 NSWCCA case Josefski versus R, which stipulates “that a person cannot be sentenced for unintended, unforeseen and not reasonably foreseeable consequences of his conduct”. And this being made out meant that the firearm could not be considered on resentencing.
In relation to the second ground, which comprised of Judge O’Rourke not distinguishing between Zahab being involved in a joint criminal enterprise and the specific role that he played in it. The appeals court found this made out, as her Honour didn’t consider that Zahab only drove the vehicle and came to the plan late. Instead, she blurred Zahab’s culpability with that of his co-accused.
Resentencing
In resentencing, NSWCCA Justice Deborah Anne Sweeney determined that the offending was at the midrange, as whilst Zahab had joined at the last minute, so he could go see his dealer, her Honour added that the guideline judgment relating to robbery offences set out in the 1999 NSWCCA case R versus Henry, found that a crime being committed to feed a drug habit was not a mitigating factor.
The NSWCCA justice further considered multiple programs that Zahab has been undertaking whilst in detention, and that he is taking buprenorphine to remedy his heroin dependence. She also considered that custody is more difficult for him due to his mental health, and therefore, she found “special circumstances”, which permitted a longer time on parole out in the community.
A finding of special circumstances, under section 44 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), provides that a parole period must not exceed a third of the head sentence, unless such circumstances are found. Therefore, a non-parole period, on finding special circumstances, should be less than 75 percent of the overall sentence. In Zahab’s case, in the end, it comprised 66 percent.
In resentencing Zahab, Justice Sweeney took into account that he pleaded guilty to a less serious offence than his co-accused and that it has a lesser maximum penalty. Further, she considered Zahab’s limited role in the offence and the matters personal to him, which included that his criminal history was less serious than that of his co-accused, and that it did not contain prior similar offending.
On 7 August 2026, Justice Sweeney quashed Zahab’s 2025 sentence, and resentenced him to 3 years and 3 months prison time, which reflected a 5 percent sentencing discount, and non-parole was set at 2 years and 2 months.
And NSW Chief Justice Andrew Bell and NSWCCA Justice Hament Dhanji both agreed with their colleague’s orders.




