Appeal Against Corruption Succeeds as Verdict Based on Scenario Not Advanced by Crown

Jon Waldron was convicted in the District Court of New South Wales over allegations he corruptly received benefits for facilitating business opportunities with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) when he was an agent of the bank.

He then appealed his convictions to the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal which recently upheld his appeal and ordered a new trial, after the appeal court found that his guilt had been predicated on a version of events the Crown had not put to the court.

The case

The Crown alleged that from 16 May 2014 to 16 December 2014, Waldron, a CBA employee, received credits amounting to US$1.9 million in his bank account, which was a reward for assisting ServiceMesh Inc (SMI) in obtaining valuable contracts with CBA. Further, over 7 August 2014 to 23 September 2014, CBA agent Keith Hunter was alleged to have obtain US$630,000 from SMI similarly.

The case against Waldron was circumstantial, as the purpose of these payments to him and Hunter was inferred. The Crown meant to show that Waldron was a CBA agent, and that the payments were for progressing SMI contracts. SMI sales consultant Bradley Twynham managed the company’s 2011 established Master Service Agreement with CBA, and he was also a close friend of Waldron.

At the time of the alleged offending, Waldron and Hunter were executive level employees at CBA. Waldron was promoted to General Manager IT Engineering in 2012, and he answered to Hunter.

US company Computer Services Corporation (CSC) moved to acquire SMI on 31 October 2013, which provided SMI shareholders with 10 times the usual revenue over “the earn period”, or the 12 months to 31 January 2014. Two major CBA contracts were entered into over this period – the McAfee and Pivotal deals – and this increased SMI gross revenue from U$20million to US$30 million.

The circumstantial evidence included that during the earn period, there were increased exchanges between Waldron and Twynham, favourable circumstances surrounding the deals, suspect payments going to Waldron’s CBA account, questionable documents with payments as a result of Waldron’s company Digisol providing services to Ace and deals being expedited to maximise profits.

The District Court proceedings

On 8 May 2024, NSW District Court Judge Phillip Mahony found Waldron guilty of seven counts of corruptly receiving or soliciting a benefit as an agent, contrary to section 249B of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). These charges related to Waldron allegedly having received payments to reward the facilitation of CBA deals. The maximum penalty for this crime is up to 7 years imprisonment.

The former CBA executive was also convicted in relation to three counts of aiding and abetting the corrupt receiving of a benefit by an agent, contrary to sections 249F and 249B of the Crimes Act. This was in relation to Waldron having allegedly assisted Hunter in receiving payments, which the latter went on to plead guilty to. And this offence carries up to 7 years imprisonment as well.

Several pieces of documentary evidence were important in the trial. Exhibit K was a three-page document retrieved from Hunter’s iPad that was a 20 June 2014 statement of work, which Waldron provided, after a question about how he’d produced his documents. Exhibit N comprised of documents from Ace principal Andy Goldstein paying Waldron and Hunter for their services.

Exhibit AAB involved documents Waldron provided to the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions on 2 September 2022, which comprised a Digisol white paper for Ace detailing work to be completed, invoices and statements of work displaying the dates produced, along with “documents relating to a digital forensic analysis of the documents, which was conducted by Lyonswood in 2018”.

The final exhibit, 117, comprised of hardcopy documents, including the statements of work and emails between Goldstien and Waldron. And the emails involved introductions between the Ace principal and Waldron regarding Digisol services.

The Crown argued that the Exhibit K document was a newly created sham, that Exhibit N comprised of newly created documents in an attempt to conceal where payments really came from and exhibits AAB and 117 were documents created after Waldron had been charged “to give the impression that they were created contemporaneously”.

Waldron put to the court that the money he received was for legitimate work done for Ace. So, the documents involved in exhibits AAB and 117 were real and corresponded with the dates upon them. The defendant added that if the court could not show the payments he received were not a result of work that his company Digisol did for Ace, then he should be acquitted.

The court cited suspicious texts between Waldron and Twynham, whilst Goldstien told the court he deleted his related emails in 2015. Waldron explained away the texts and confirmed that payments he received were in response to work completed for Ace. He added that the Exhibit AAB documents were created on the dates they bore. And on cross-examination, none of this was disproven.

Judge Mahony found that Waldron and Hunter had facilitated the McAfee and Pivotal deals during the earn period, and that the AAB and 117 documents were produced and sent on the date related to them. So, ultimately, his Honour found that the Goldstein exchanges with Waldron were fabricated to facilitate the conveyance of the SMI financial rewards to the defendant for preferential treatment.

The NSW District Court judge then sentenced Waldron to 6 years and 8 months imprisonment on 8 May 2024, with non-parole set at 4 years.

The appeal

Waldron appealed the outcome of his case to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal (NSWCCA) on 11 September this year. And he did so based on one ground, which comprised of a miscarriage of justice having taken place due to denial of procedural fairness via the making of findings which did not accord with the way the Crown case was put.

NSWCCA Justice Christine Adamson explained that in the 2006 NSWCCA case Robinson versus R, Justice Peter Johnson set out that a criminal trial involves guilt being established beyond a reasonable doubt, whilst the judge remains impartial. And the judge should not, on summing up, advance a scenario revealing guilt that was not initially part of the Crown case.

Judge Mahony had not accepted the Crown’s version of events that documents involved in exhibits AAB and 117 were falsified papers created after Waldron was charged, based on evidence that this was not possible due to their metadata. And her Honour instead based her findings of guilt on the documents produced in 2014, that she considered facilitated the corrupt SMI payments.

These findings, Justice Adamson outlined, “did not correspond with any submission put by the parties. It was a finding adverse to the applicant which did not accord with the way the Crown had put its case at trial and was not therefore part of the case which the applicant had to meet. The Crown had not cross-examined the applicant on this alternative basis”.

“Neither the Crown nor the applicant’s trial counsel had addressed on this matter, except to confirm (in the case of the Crown) that it would not be fair for the trial judge to make such a finding and to note (in the case of the applicant’s trial counsel) that the alternative submission had not been put by the Crown,” her Honour further reasoned.

Ground one was therefore made out, and Justice Adamson then advised that the proviso contained in subsection 6(1) of the Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW) had to be considered. The proviso provides that if a verdict is to be set aside on appeal due to a miscarriage of justice, the court should then decide whether the miscarriage is of no substantial consequence, and if so, dismiss the appeal.

Her Honour found that the proviso should not hold in Waldron’s case, as the trial outcome relied on the judge accepting a substantial part of the accused’s case – that the documents were created on their original dates – however, she then made an adverse finding against the accused on upholding the defence assertion.

As guilt beyond reasonable doubt was not a certainty, therefore, a substantial miscarriage of justice had occurred, and the proviso was not made out.

The orders

On 7 October 2026, Justice Adamson ruled that both Waldron’s convictions and his sentence both come to in the District Court respectively in May and September 2024 should be quashed, and the accused should then face retrial in the lower court.

And NSWCCA Justices Richard McHugh and Peter Hamill agreed with their colleague’s orders.

Author Image

About Sydney Criminal Lawyers

Sydney Criminal Lawyers® is Australia's Leading Criminal Defence Law Firm, Delivering Outstanding Results in All Australian Courts. Going to Court? Call (02) 9261 8881 for a Free Consultation.